Skip to content

Best Baby Crib Mattress Buying Guide

The quality of the mattress in your baby’s crib has a strong impact on the little one’s development. Many people don’t pay much attention to this particular item, but poor sleeping posture during the first months of one’s life can deal some permanent damage to the musculoskeletal system and have a few other negative effects on your child’s development. If you want to protect your precious infant from these problems, you’ll need to look for the best baby crib mattress on the market.

Table of Content:

  1. Comparison chart of best baby crib mattress
  2. Top 5 product reviews of best baby crib mattress
  3. Tips for choosing the best baby crib mattress
  4. How to get pee stains out of a crib mattress
  5. In conclusion

Comparison Chart of Best Baby Crib Mattresses

Newton $$$$4.8
Serta Nightstar Deluxe$$$$4.8
Dream On Me$$4.7
My First Mattress$$4.6
Safety 1st$$4.6
Sealy Soybean$$$$4.6
Sealy Soybean$$4.6
Simmons Kids Slumber$$4.5

Top 5 Product Reviews for the Best Baby Crib Mattresses

5. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

Sealy is the leader of the crib mattress market for a reason. This company produces a great number of excellent products that can meet every parent’s requirements. This particular piece is considered the best baby crib mattress from Sealy due to its unique construction and outstanding quality. It features the manufacturer’s specialty, a soybean foam core certified under the Greenguard Gold standard. The foam is durable and firm enough to provide infants with maximum comfort during their sleep.

The mattress cover is waterproof and very easy to clean. Every part of the mattress is made from the highest quality materials that have been tested and certified, so you can be sure that your baby will be safe. The product is hypoallergenic, so there are no health risks, even for the most sensitive babies.

The reviewers agree that this baby crib mattress is of an excellent quality. Mothers often complement the fact that it’s very light and easy to handle. Many people also commend the quality and ‘springiness’ of the foam as well as durability of the product.

Find out the cost of Sealy Soybean Foam Crib Mattress on Amazon.

4. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

This is one of the most popular products on the market and it’s definitely the best baby crib mattress for those who seek an affordable and safe item. This piece offers everything you’d be looking for in a premium-quality product at a fraction of its price.

The mattress is lightweight, and Greenguard Gold certified, so you don’t have to worry about it being toxic for your baby. It also meets the federal flammability standard (16 CFR 1633), though it’s not treated with any dangerous fire retardants.

The vinyl cover is free of lead, phthalates, and any other nasty chemicals. The product is considered hypoallergenic and non-toxic. The cover is easy to clean and the mattress dries fast after washing. Even a leaking nappy won’t leave permanent stains. Note that this type of cover is easy to sanitize. The mattress core is made from thermo-bonded fiber. It supports your baby perfectly, providing their spine the support necessary for healthy development.

This mattress from Safety 1st has hundreds of glowing reviews. People love that it offers great value for the money, and it’s extremely durable. Many owners donate or even resell the pieces after their babies get too big for them, so purchasing this product seems to be a wise investment. The majority of ‘users’ state the ease of cleaning and sanitation is the best thing about the piece.

Check out the current Amazon price for Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress.

3. My First Mattress Memory Foam Crib Mattress

This outstanding product by My First Mattress is made from top-quality polyurethane foam. The material is CertiPUR-US certified, so you can be sure that it’s perfectly safe for the baby. The piece meets all the necessary flammability and quality standards and the foam density is perfect to provide proper support to your baby’s spine.

This is the best baby crib mattress for you if you are looking for an affordable high-quality piece that can be transferred to a toddler’s bed. The quality and density of the foam ensure that it’s up for the challenge. According to the vast majority of reviews, you can be confident that the mattress will be as good as new for over 3 years, which is a very impressive term for a memory foam piece. Many reviewers complement the waterproof cover, which is easy to both clean and sanitize. The product is anti-microbial and mite-proof, as well as hypoallergenic. Your child will be safe sleeping on it every day, even if they are sensitive to common allergens.

Learn the Amazon price of My First Mattress Memory Foam Crib Mattress today.

2. Dream On Me Spring Twilight Crib and Toddler Baby Mattress

The Twilight from Dream On Me is the best baby crib mattress for those who want to buy a durable top-quality item. The springs in it are heat-tempered and interwoven to provide optimal support for the child’s spine.

The cover is triple-laminated, waterproof, and stain resistant. You will be able to clean it with a sponge and a bit of soapy water. A leaking nappy won’t cause any permanent damage to the product.

The mattress also features a layer of tested fire blocker, and the product as a whole meets the 16 CFR 1632/1633 Federal Flammability Standards. It’s perfectly safe for the baby as it doesn’t contain any potentially toxic chemicals. The extra-durable stainless steel coils are covered with a hypoallergenic polyurethane foam layer on both sides, so your baby is sure to feel comfortable.

The reviewers state that the mattress is very durable and easy to handle. Despite the fact that it’s an innerspring type of construction, it’s not particularly heavy. The piece fits the majority of cribs and toddler beds, and it’s durable enough to serve you well until your baby grows up enough to get a bigger bed.

Take a look at the current cost of Dream On Me Twilight Crib Mattress on Amazon.

1. Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

This is another premium-quality product from Sealy, and it’s the best baby crib mattress among innersprings. The piece features 204 interwoven steel coils that can support your baby for years to come. Sealy also uses a specialized weight distribution system to enhance the little one’s comfort and durability of the product.

This mattress comes with a hospital-grade waterproof cover, which is perfectly safe for the baby and stain resistant. You can clean and sanitize it within minutes, and ensure your precious infant is safe from bacteria. Due to the extended durability of the product, you can transfer it to a toddler bed or sell if after your baby grows too big for it.

According to the vast majority of reviews, the Baby Firm mattress from Sealy makes an excellent investment. Some people dislike the ‘plasticky’ feel of the cover, but this problem is easily solved by using soft jersey cotton sheets or a fitted crib sheet.

Learn the Amazon price of Sealy Baby Firm Mattress.

Tips for Choosing the Best Baby Crib Mattress

You should start with studying your options, as there are hundreds of mattresses for you to choose from. They differ in materials, thickness, cores, and sizes. Each factor is important in its own way and you need to understand the differences between the available types to make the healthiest choice for your baby.

  • Innerspring vs. foam.
    Crib mattresses usually come in two types, innerspring and foam. Both are good and can provide your baby’s spine with proper support during hours of sleeping. Innerspring mattresses are ‘sturdier’ and much more durable, especially if the quality of the product is high. The springs offer a good support and many of these pieces are of the 2-in-1 variety, which fits both infants and toddlers. Note that a quality product should have no less than 135 springs of 15.5 gauge. You also need to consider that these items can be rather heavy, which can be a problem for a mother as you’ll need to lift the mattress to change the sheets at least once a week.
    Foam mattresses are much lighter and nowadays, you can find premium-quality organic foam that offers good support and is perfectly safe for a newborn. If you choose this option, you need to look for a product of high-to-moderate density so that it will effectively adjust to the infant’s body. The best baby crib mattress made of foam should be springy and regain its original shape fast.
  • Organic vs. non-organic.
    In the vast majority of cases, it’s safer to use organic only baby products. However, it’s not an essential requirement as there are many high-quality mattresses that are safe for newborns. The most important thing you need to look for is the absence of dangerous chemicals, especially some toxic fire retardants.
    Please note that many products that claim to be organic contain only a small amount of materials that are truly organic. For example, any waterproof model is sure to have some chemicals as there aren’t waterproof organic materials.
  • Material.
    The best baby crib mattress is a complex structure that consists of numerous layers. Some of the materials that might go into the mix are cotton, bamboo, soy foam, wool, vinyl, polyurethane, steel, and a great number of others. You should study a detailed description of every piece you consider to make sure that none of the materials are potentially hazardous to the child. At this point, you will need to decide how ‘natural’ you want the mattress to be. For example, many people are wary of vinyl covers because they are synthetic. However, they’ve been tested and proven safe by generations. They also make mattresses waterproof and easy to clean.
  • Ventilation.
    Every mattress needs to have good ventilation so that the baby can breathe comfortably while sleeping. Pieces that don’t allow for efficient air flow are a hazard, especially during the summer as they make the little one overheat. Mattresses with waterproof covers always have poorer ventilation than cotton and wool pieces, so they must be equipped with special vent holes and pockets that allow the air to flow freely.

There are many other factors you might take into account when shopping for a crib mattress, including the cost, brand, springiness, thickness, etc. The most important thing you need to remember is that you should get the best product you can find and buy only from reputed and certified manufacturers. This way, you can be sure that your baby will be safe and comfortable.

How to get pee stains out of a crib mattress

In Conclusion

Shopping for the best baby crib mattress is a very important task, so be sure to study your options very carefully. Buy products from leading manufacturers that have certifications, which prove the materials are safe for babies.

Whether you decide to buy an organic or synthetic piece, remember that quality, ventilation, and fire resistance are the most important features of a crib mattress. Study a few reviews to make sure you can trust the product you are about to purchase. Also, take a look at our review of good rated toddler mattresses.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.