The comfortable sleeping place is crucial for a growing organism and its proper development. So, there are many important points to keep in mind while choosing the best toddler mattress. Actually, although replacing of the crib by a normal kid’s bed happens at about 18-36 months, an infant mattress and a toddler mattress are usually of the same size. That’s why many parents prefer two-sided mattresses that will fit both the cot and the toddler bed. On the other hand, obviously not all beds are created equal, so the dimensions of the bed of the crib must be measured thoroughly before making up a decision, especially if you don’t visit a store and want to purchase your mattress online.
In any case, it should be chosen carefully, because when a spine grows it needs reliable support and healthy conditions to become sound and strong. In addition, children are very different in their activity level, skin type and simply personal preferences, so finding the product of your dream may seem a hard task. However, taking into account several essential points will make it an easy matter to manage.
Table of Content:
- Comparison chart of best toddler mattresses
- Independent review of toddler mattresses
- Main qualities that matter when seeking the best toddler mattress
- How to clean a mattress!
- How does the ideal toddler mattress finally look like?
Comparison chart of best toddler mattresses
| Picture | Name | Warranty | Origin | Price | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Newton | Not listed | USA | $$$ | 5.0 |
 | Naturepedic | Not listed | USA | $$ | 4.8 |
 | Serta | Not listed | Not listed | $$ | 4.7 |
 | Sealy | lifetime warranty on workmanship and materials | USA | $$ | 4.6 |
 | Safety 1st | 2 years | Not listed | $$ | 4.5 |
 | Simmons | 35 years | USA | $$ | 4.5 |
 | My First Mattress | 10 years | Not listed | $$ | 4.5 |
 | Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams | 2 years | Canada | $$ | 4.4 |
 | Sealy Nature Couture | Lifetime warranty on workmanship and materials | USA | $$ | 4.2 |
 | Dream On Me | 10 years | USA | $$ | 4.2 |
Independent reviews of top rated toddler mattresses
5. Safety 1st Transitions Baby and Toddler Mattress
This is a standard two-sided mattress, suitable both for infants and for toddlers. An additional cushioning level on the toddler side provides more comfort and ensures serene sleep. The product has Greenguard Gold Certification and meets federal flammability standard 16 CFR 1633 without the use of any potentially harmful chemicals. Its surface is waterproof and wipes clean very easily. The dimensions of 27.5 x 52 x 5 inches are acceptable both for cribs and toddler beds.
The reviewers admit that such a great combination of many advantages in one item is sold under the very just price, which enhances its attractiveness even more. The firmness is perfectly balanced on both sizes: the mattress is neither too stiff nor too soft. The mattress fits snug in the bed, eliminating the risks of baby’s slipping their limbs into the gaps between the bed edge and the mattress. Many buyers also mention the high quality of this item which makes it lasts longer than two of three years.
4. Cozy Rest 2-Stage Crib Mattress by Sealy
The toddler side of this famous baby care brand boasts an extra plush cotton layer on the toddler side, which provides luxurious comfort. The innerspring structure of 204 premium steel coils and border wire along the edges ensures proper support for the spine, and 6 ever edge strength pillars protect baby near corner and sides. The outer cover is water resistant and enhanced with STAPH-GARD to provide an antibacterial and antistatic surface that repels moisture, dirt, and allergens. On the side of this model, a natural air flow pocket is placed that allows fresh air circulating through the mattress. Despite its steel-containing structure, the whole thing has a relatively light weight of 14.9 pounds, which makes it easy to handle. Sealy was voted for America’s best brand for babies in2019 and2019, so it’s definitely a place to pay your attention to while searching for the best toddler mattress.
Almost every review marks the very nice and pleasant by touch fabric that is, in addition, 100% waterproof. Moderate weight of the product allows changing bed sheets without any problem. The size fits well standard cots or baby beds, and chemical-free filling causes no weird smells, so the chances that your child will like it increase a lot.
3. Tranquility Eco Firm Toddler Mattress by Serta
This comfortable product by Serta is another bright representative of eco mattresses and hence it is one of the best toddler mattresses. It includes 120 heavy duty innerspring coils and is hardened by the full perimeter border wire. Ortho-insulated layer brings necessary support for the baby’s spine. On the toddler side, there’s an additional organic cotton layer for extra comfort. Standard 27.5 x 52 x 6-inch dimensions fit all common types of children’s beds. The model is Greenguard gold certified.
The notable comfort of the toddler side is marked by many reviews. It has special tags in the upper left corner to easily indicate which side is which. Waterproof qualities of the cover are highly estimated by the clients as well, so there’s no need to be afraid that the mattress gets damaged if the diaper leaks or a baby occasionally spits up. This model also is thick and firm enough to withstand many years of use. It even boasts an unbelievable 50-year warranty.
2. Lightweight Dual Firmness Crib Mattress by Naturepedic
A mattress of this kind embodies a very firm and comfortable exclusive wave support technology developed and patented by Naturepedic. Its cover of 100% organic cotton layers is water resistant and so pure that it meets food contact standards. The seams are waterproof as well, which prevents the liquid penetration inside the mattress and the product from getting ruined. The material of filling is pure food-grade polyethylene, which makes this model very light and easy to deal with during the bed sheets changing. The product meets Greenguard safety standards.
Reviews mention the excellent organic qualities and useful tags and arrows that mark infant and toddler sides of the mattress. The price is also very decent for a product, the quality of which allows it to stay usable for many years. A number of buyers warn to mind the proper size fit. This model can be a bit smaller than announced in some cases. However, if it happens, the provider will replace the small item with that of a right size with no problem.
1. Newton Toddler Bed Mattress – The Best Toddler Mattress
It’s rather original and innovative product in the best toddler mattress category. Its three-dimensional fabric structure is totally free from foam, springs, latex, glue and other widely used materials. This is a rare type of completely washable mattress, which helps the item to maintain the highest hygienic level. Breathable design allows the children to respire freely, regardless of the position they are sleeping in, and significantly reduces the risk of suffocation. Constant air circulation prevents overheating and eliminates excessive sweating. This outstanding model boasts a number of awards, including the2019 JPMA Innovation Award.
Reviewers confirm the highest quality of the breathable materials this model is made of and its extreme comfort in use. Although it’s not too firm, for toddlers this mattress will be a perfect choice that provides them both with required spinal support and coziness for the healthy sleep. Of course, the unique design that notably decreases the risk of SIDS is another significant advantage of the product, as many children prefer to rest on their stomachs in a certain age, or can occasionally turn face down while being asleep. Despite being a rather expensive choice, it’s definitely worth every penny.
Main Qualities That Matter When Seeking the Best Toddler Mattress
- Inner structure.
The innerspring mattress will surely be the most appropriate choice for toddlers. It’s durable enough to last from 3 to 5 years, before a need to replace it arises. Latex mattresses are softer, but they’ve got a tendency to take a body shape after a year of use. Memory foam mattresses turn out to be absolutely unsuitable for children’s beds as they don’t provide enough support. In addition, the foam gets damaged quickly by the liquid. - The quality of materials.
Of course, organic materials are preferable for the best toddler mattress, especially if your baby has sensitive skin or is prone to allergies. This option may be a bit pricey, but if the structure is innerspring and allows the item to last for a long time, the health issues undoubtedly should prevail. The toddler side of two-sided mattresses usually has the softer cover than the infant side. Many brands also offer mattresses with a waterproof surface, which makes them extremely convenient in use. - Weight
Weight really matters, as turning the mattress on the opposite side or lifting it to put the bed sheets in order is quite a frequent job to do. That’s why the chosen item shouldn’t remind a block of cement while handling it. On the other hand, the too light mattress may have poorer supportive qualities unless it’s made using some innovative technologies that allow significant reducing of the weight while still keeping the firmness on a proper level. - Size
The size should fit the toddler bed completely, with no gapping and space through which a baby can occasionally slide a foot while sleeping. Thus, the risk of SIDS can be eliminated. Keep in mind that in some cases there can be a slight difference in dimensions of a real product from those given by the website, so it’s better to check it in advance if possible. - Firmness
Generally, all small children need hard mattresses to support their growing bodies in a right way. This rule is stricter for infants than for toddlers, but in the latter case, firm innerspring mattress with a soft and comfortable topping layer will be an ideal choice. - Comfort
Firmness is crucial, although the best toddler mattress, shouldn’t feel stony. Everyone has their own concerns regarding comfort, so testing the product before buying it is a nice idea. Of course, the child still cannot do it by themselves, but for you, if you are not purchasing the mattress via Internet, it’s no problem to lie down on a chosen item in the store and at least try to evaluate the comfort level of its outer cover.
How to clean a mattress!
As we know how our kids mess up their mattress, there can be harbor spills, stains, dirt, dust, dust mites and worse – so, maintaining a clean mattress is important for several reasons.
How Does the Ideal Toddler Mattress Finally Look Like?
To sum the information up, it’s possible to try describing an image of the best toddler mattress that will be universal almost for everybody. Looks like it will be a two-sided high-quality durable mattress of the size both suitable for toddler beds and for cribs, with 100% organic, hypoallergenic, soft and breathable cover that is waterproof in addition. Greenguard certification is recommended. The firmness should be balanced as to provide enough support for the baby’s back and head and, at the same time, be a mild and cozy nest to sleep in. Also, mind the weight that should leave an opportunity for you to lift and turn the thing easily when the need arises. Finally, check the range of prices thoroughly as there are enough products on the market that offer the completely reliable quality for the just price, so there’s no sense in overpaying.
Also, read my review of best baby towels that are hooded to make shower exciting for your child.