Skip to content

5 Top Rated Crib Mattresses

5 Top Rated Crib Mattresses Reviews

As infants sleep up to 16 hours a day and toddlers tend to sleep about 11-13 hours a day on average, the importance of providing a good sleeping environment for your kid can hardly be overestimated. Not only will you ensure a cozy sleep by using a top rated crib mattress, but will generally promote healthy conditions to support your kid’s bones growth as well as provide some basic safety measures.

Choosing a good mattress for your child’s crib is equally important to getting any other kid’s gear such as baby toys, a car seat, or a crib itself. You will find several types of crib mattresses on the market, so choosing the one that fits best might be quite daunting. Although most of them will seem pretty much the same at first sight, there are some important details which you may occasionally miss if you don’t know what to look for in a crib mattress.

While the must-have checklist for your crib mattress won’t be too long when you’re in the market for the baby essentials, make sure the one you buy meets manufacturing standards and provides the qualities you need.

Table of Content:

  1. Comparison chart of best crib mattresses
  2. The best crib mattresses available in the market
  3. Buying guidance of crib mattresses
  4. In conclusion

Comparison Chart of Best Crib Mattresses

Dream On Me10 yearsUSA$$$5.0
Kolcraft1 yearUSA$$4.9
Dream On Me 3Not listedUSA$$4.8
Safety 1st 1 yearNot listed$$$$4.8
Sealy EM438-VIV120 years on workmanship and materialsUSA$$4.7
Moonlight Slumber Not listedUSA$$$$4.7
My First Mattress 10 yearsUSA$$$$4.6
Sealy Soybean FoamLifetime warranty on workmanship and materialsUSA$$$$4.6
NewtonNot listedUSA$$$$4.6
Milliard Not listedChina$$$4.5

The Best Crib Mattresses Available on the Market

5.Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress


This great 100% waterproof hypoallergenic mattress with terry surface has deserved to be called one of the top rated crib mattresses for many reasons. The renowned manufacturer offers a 20-year full replacement warranty due to the premium protection against stains and liquids. It also provides the product made of non-toxic organic materials such as 100% cotton as well as ensures superior quality, durability, and ease of clean.

This particular model is equipped with a breathable membrane allowing air through to discharge excessive moisture and prevent bed bugs and mold. The fabric is machine washable in cool water and requires no harsh cleaning detergents.

The majority of the reviewers like this model for the excellent protection it provides due to its Sure Guard mattress protector as well as its quality surface material which is waterproof and easy-to-wash. In addition, the item produces no sound, has even seams, and comes at a competitive price.

Learn more details about this product on Amazon.

4. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

white crib mattress

When looking for a top rated crib mattress, make sure to pay your attention to this excellent model made of high-density foam providing firm support, long-lasting use, and great durability. Inside the mattress, there is a specially designed thermo-bonded material which provides perfect body support while its hydrophobic laminated outer cover ensures all the liquids stay outside no matter how much has been spilled over.

Since the item is GREENGUARD GOLD certified, it meets high indoor emission standards to provide safe sleeping environment throughout your child’s development. In addition, the surface fabric is wear, tear, and odor resistant so you won’t have to worry it will lose its original appearance and quality in a couple of years.

There are plenty of positive reviews of this product which serve to prove its premium quality and excellent performance. Many parents are satisfied with it and state the mattress is firm enough for newborns.

Check the Amazon price of this model.

3. Dream On Me 3 Portable Crib Mattress

portable crib mattress

This firm top rated crib mattress is surely a safe place for your newborn to sleep on since it conforms to high flammability, antibacterial production standards, and has passed some serious toxic emission tests. It’s free of phthalates and lead which means you can be 100% sure of your child’s healthy sleeping environment.

The product dimensions (38 x 24 x 3 inches) will allow this model fit most cribs while its comparatively small weight (only 1.9 pounds) means the item is not cumbersome at all

The majority of the reviews on this model are quite positive. The main advantage they point out is the model’s firmness combined with a high level of comfort and safety. Most parents admit the mattress is firm but not rock hard. In addition, it’s lightweight and fits most portable cribs which are great features if your lifestyle implies moving around with your newborn a lot.

Go here to get more product details on Amazon.

2. Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Crib Mattress

comfortable crib mattress

When looking for an extremely durable and water resistant top rated crib mattress, check out this model from Kolcraft. Along with standard features you can find in many crib mattresses such as flammability, hypoallergenic materials, and high density for improved comfort, this model offers a flat surface with no straps or buckles to ensure the highest level of safety for infants. In addition, the seams are equipped with an additional protection against liquids preventing excessive moisture getting inside that may lead to mold and bacteria.

Since the surface of this model is flat and strapless, it’s easy to clean and maintain while the foam inside is supportive enough to try his/her first own movements yet comfy for a peaceful sleep.

The majority of the reviews of this product state that the model is the perfect combination of quality and pricing. It has also been a choice of many parents since the mattress’s weight (2.1 pounds) allows for a great portability.

Learn more about Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Crib Mattress on Amazon.

1. Dream On Me Spring Crib And Toddler Bed Mattress

top rated crib mattress

If you’re thinking of getting an excellent bed for your child, this top rated crib mattress with a double hypoallergenic layer is certainly a great choice. The model offers 80 coils made of tempered metal which provide comfortable firmness and excellent support. In addition, all the springs are interconnected while the 6-gauge wire around helps to keep them in place.

Mold, mildew, and bacteria are no longer an issue with this mattress since its locked seams provide enhanced protection from inside leakages. Its coils are wrapped in polyurethane foam for a supreme sleeping experience while the organic materials make the model safe for your kids. For improved flexibility, the model fits all standard full-size cribs and toddler beds.

Many reviewers have opted for this model due to its durability and longevity. In many cases, it used to serve for several babies in the family without losing its qualities within a long period of time. Besides, the model comes at a fair price which is also a plus.

Find out more about this item on Amazon.

Top Rated Crib Mattress Buying Guide

  • The type of the mattress.
    Basically, there are two types of mattresses to choose from: foam and innerspring.
    The foam mattress is generally cheaper and lighter. It comes in a variety of thicknesses between 3 and 6 inches. However, thickness is not the most important factor to consider. The property which is more vital for a foam mattress is its density that is normally measured in pounds per cubic foot. Mattresses with higher density (over 1.5 pounds per cubic foot) are considered to be firm enough to provide bedding safety against sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) to lower the chance that your kid suffocates in the sleep.
    Normally, a foam mattress will weigh about 2 to 5 pounds. However, some memory foam models may weigh around 10 pounds which can be an issue if you will need to lift it out of the crib too often.
    Resilience is another factor to consider when buying foam-based bedding. Top rated crib mattresses will always recover their shape fast after you lie down, sit, or push into them.
    An innerspring mattress will normally be more expensive since it can show better durability and longevity. While many manufacturers advertise the number of coils as the main advantage of their product, factors such as the size and the type of the wire as well as the number of turns per spring are equally important.
  • The proper size.
    Due to the safety issues, the crib mattresses have to fit snugly into the crib so that there’s no space for your kid to wedge an arm or a leg by getting stuck between the mattress and the crib. You should normally apply the two-finger rule to ensure the gap is safe and the mattress is not too small for your crib. In some countries, the size of the crib mattress is determined by law to ensure proper safety measures for the newborns and toddlers.
  • The mattress indoor emission.
    Since indoor air quality is closely linked to our health, testing furniture for indoor emissions has become a common procedure to certify home furnishings including some top rated crib mattresses. That is why a growing number of parents choose bedding equipment for their kids made of organic materials containing no toxic compounds. Although this significantly raises the price of the mattress you buy, for many it’s worth the cost since you may avoid lots of diseases in infants including early allergic reactions.
  • The mattress surface.
    Since the kid’s bed is normally a subject to harsh wear and tear conditions, having a reinforced ticking that is waterproof and can withstand diaper leaks or bottle food spillage is highly recommended. Even if you plan to use a washable waterproof cover to protect the mattress, you will still need to clean it with a damp cloth and mild soap from time to time. So make sure the surface can withstand it.

In Conclusion

Choosing a top rated crib mattress for your child is a serious task which should be done with a high level of responsibility. When it comes to choosing the best, you should really consider all the features a particular mattress provides since not all of the options available on the market are worth spending your money on.

No matter how many stores you hit, you will normally have little chance to tell a mattress only by its cover. Like with the majority of kid’s gear, the safety requirements, as well as quality tests results, should be your main considerations. Since your newborn or toddler will spend a lot of time in the crib, it’s recommended to buy the best one you can. Finally, don’t pay too much attention to marketing tricks and try to get all the information you can about the model you’re about to buy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.